"Energy is money" is a provocative analogy that highlights the deep interdependence between energy and economic value. At its core, it means that energy is the foundational currency of productivity, wealth creation, and modern civilization—more fundamental than fiat money, which is just a proxy for it.
Here’s a breakdown of why this idea holds water:
1. Energy Enables All Economic Activity
Every good or service requires energy to produce.
From mining raw materials to manufacturing, transportation, heating, computing, or even thinking (your brain runs on ~20 watts), nothing happens without energy input.
Historical correlation: Economies grow in lockstep with energy consumption.
The Industrial Revolution exploded when coal unlocked massive mechanical work.
The 20th century’s growth rode on oil.
Today, GDP per capita scales almost linearly with per capita energy use across nations.
Example: A factory producing $1M in goods doesn’t create value from thin air—it burns fuel, electricity, and human calories (food energy) to transform matter.
2. Money Is a Claim on Energy
Fiat currencies (USD, EUR) have no intrinsic value—they’re IOUs backed by trust and productivity.
But productivity = applied energy + human ingenuity.
Therefore:
$1 = a socially accepted claim on a certain amount of useful work (energy directed toward human goals).
Think of inflation: When too much money chases limited goods (i.e., limited energy-transformed products), prices rise. Money loses purchasing power because energy supply didn’t keep up.
3. Energy Has Physical Limits—Money Does Not
You can print dollars, but you can’t print joules (without massive energy input—e.g., fusion, which we don’t have yet).
This makes energy the ultimate scarce resource, while money is abundant by decree.
Thermodynamic truth: All wealth ultimately traces back to low-entropy energy (concentrated fuels, sunlight, uranium) being converted into high-entropy waste (heat, CO₂) to organize matter.
4. Energy Return on Investment (EROI) = Real Wealth
Not all energy is equal.
Falling EROI means more energy (and money) must be spent to get energy—shrinking the surplus that funds everything else (schools, iPhones, space travel).
A society with high EROI lives like a billionaire.
A society with low EROI lives paycheck to paycheck.
5. Extreme Case: No Energy = No Economy
Imagine a total blackout:
ATMs don’t work.
Trucks don’t deliver food.
Servers hosting your crypto go dark.
Money becomes worthless paper (or bits) without energy to honor claims on goods/services.
Counterpoint: Is It Too Reductionist?
Yes, human creativity, institutions, and culture matter. Energy alone doesn’t build cathedrals or write symphonies.
But without energy, none of that happens. Creativity is the software; energy is the hardware.
Conclusion:
"Energy is money" means:
Money is a derivative abstraction. Energy is the root currency—the ability to do work, to move atoms, to defy entropy locally.
All wealth, all progress, all power (political and economic) ultimately flows from who controls and efficiently converts energy.
So when someone says “energy is money,” they’re not being metaphorical—they’re pointing to the physical foundation of economics, hidden beneath layers of finance, policy, and hype.
Fun thought: Bitcoin miners don’t “print” money—they convert electricity into digital scarcity. They’re literally turning joules into dollars. Energy is money.
Here’s a breakdown of why this idea holds water:
1. Energy Enables All Economic Activity
Every good or service requires energy to produce.
From mining raw materials to manufacturing, transportation, heating, computing, or even thinking (your brain runs on ~20 watts), nothing happens without energy input.
Historical correlation: Economies grow in lockstep with energy consumption.
The Industrial Revolution exploded when coal unlocked massive mechanical work.
The 20th century’s growth rode on oil.
Today, GDP per capita scales almost linearly with per capita energy use across nations.
Example: A factory producing $1M in goods doesn’t create value from thin air—it burns fuel, electricity, and human calories (food energy) to transform matter.
2. Money Is a Claim on Energy
Fiat currencies (USD, EUR) have no intrinsic value—they’re IOUs backed by trust and productivity.
But productivity = applied energy + human ingenuity.
Therefore:
$1 = a socially accepted claim on a certain amount of useful work (energy directed toward human goals).
Think of inflation: When too much money chases limited goods (i.e., limited energy-transformed products), prices rise. Money loses purchasing power because energy supply didn’t keep up.
3. Energy Has Physical Limits—Money Does Not
You can print dollars, but you can’t print joules (without massive energy input—e.g., fusion, which we don’t have yet).
This makes energy the ultimate scarce resource, while money is abundant by decree.
Thermodynamic truth: All wealth ultimately traces back to low-entropy energy (concentrated fuels, sunlight, uranium) being converted into high-entropy waste (heat, CO₂) to organize matter.
4. Energy Return on Investment (EROI) = Real Wealth
Not all energy is equal.
Falling EROI means more energy (and money) must be spent to get energy—shrinking the surplus that funds everything else (schools, iPhones, space travel).
A society with high EROI lives like a billionaire.
A society with low EROI lives paycheck to paycheck.
5. Extreme Case: No Energy = No Economy
Imagine a total blackout:
ATMs don’t work.
Trucks don’t deliver food.
Servers hosting your crypto go dark.
Money becomes worthless paper (or bits) without energy to honor claims on goods/services.
Counterpoint: Is It Too Reductionist?
Yes, human creativity, institutions, and culture matter. Energy alone doesn’t build cathedrals or write symphonies.
But without energy, none of that happens. Creativity is the software; energy is the hardware.
Conclusion:
"Energy is money" means:
Money is a derivative abstraction. Energy is the root currency—the ability to do work, to move atoms, to defy entropy locally.
All wealth, all progress, all power (political and economic) ultimately flows from who controls and efficiently converts energy.
So when someone says “energy is money,” they’re not being metaphorical—they’re pointing to the physical foundation of economics, hidden beneath layers of finance, policy, and hype.
Fun thought: Bitcoin miners don’t “print” money—they convert electricity into digital scarcity. They’re literally turning joules into dollars. Energy is money.
Myrosesdiary.
Comments
Post a Comment
Feel free to comment below